A greater question that this story leads me to is whether it is beneficial for children to be adopted by parents of a different race or ethnic group. There have been many debates and studies lead concerning how these adoptions affects these children. Some studies are focused on the benefits children receive by being adopted to another ethnic group, while others focus on the disadvantages and negative aspects of the children growing up.
These studies show that some children may have identity issues and not truly know who they are and also how children turn UT to be perfectly comfortable and open to the idea of being raised differently than their peers. An area of interest for researchers is the benefits of being adopted to parents of a different race. Researchers find that children that are transversally adopted have higher self-esteem and are more open minded than the average child grown up in the same ethnic group household.
Need essay sample on Transracial Adoption ?We will write a custom essay samplespecifically for you for only $13.90/pageorder now
According to several adoption agencies, “Psychological studies have found that transversally adopted children appear to handle the identity issues all adopted children face better than most because, searchers theorize, they cannot pretend to be like everyone else” (Interracial Families). These children understand that they are different than other children and that they do not have the traditional family in America. These children tend to easily relate to other cultures and “can bridge the culture gap”(elementarily Families) between races.
Researchers definitely have their opinions and statistics about the negative aspect and disadvantages of being adopted by parents of a different race. Researchers find that people tend to display prejudice and discrimination against diverse families. Strangers may ask derogatory questions about the child in the presence of the parents. For example, a black couple that adopted a white daughter had to deal with people following them out of “the mall to make sure she wasn’t being kidnapped” (Decouple). The National Association of Black Social Workers feel strongly about the topic.
They feel that “[b]lack children should be placed only with black families whether in foster care or adoption. Black children belong physically, psychologically and culturally in black families in order that they receive the total ensue of themselves and develop a sound projection of their future” (Future of Children). Even though some experts find that children benefit from these diverse families, others find that “[b]lack children in white homes are cut off from the healthy back to our communities and work to end this particular form of genocide”(Future of Children).
Families that decide to adopt transversally have to strive a lot harder to make their family coexist and to have a happy life, while traditional families do not face as much of the challenges. Studies show that families may have break language, identity, and call barriers for their children to feel accepted and loved Just as if they were there from birth. In the documentary, “Woo Ai In Mommy’ meaning, “l love you Mommy’, Donna and Jeff Shadow’s have to go through challenges to integrate their adopted daughter from China to feel welcomed and loved.
This family has to face the harsh challenges of not being able to directly communicate with their daughter and teach her that she is different from them and her Journey of her new life will not be easy but she has the support and love to help her along the way. According to Joana Wolff, parents also have other challenges by staying one step ahead of their child because they have to be ready to deal with the changes of their life.
For example, “transversally adopted children do not have the advantage of learning about their birth culture through everyday cues and bits of knowledge, assimilated almost unconsciously over years, as in single-race families”(Wolf. Parents have to adapt to the child’s culture as well as integrate their very own culture so the child can learn more about themselves. The mixing of cultures and religion are also a great debate about adopting ransack children. For a couple to have one religion and the child that has another is a bit off hassle to deal with in the household.
For example if a couple is Christian and they adopt a child from India, there is a boundary that the parents have to discuss and become one as a family. “Most adoptive parents raise their children in the faith they practice at home, but do not expose them to the cultural heritage of their birth country'(Rotten). Religion is something the parents have to address and share with their children. Like most parents, they will raise their children with the elision they practice and let the children decide when they are out of the house or eighteen to decide what they want for themselves.
According to Joshua Patella, “situations like these are common and normal for families to go through. ” These studies show that transversal adoption can be a beneficial to children, but there are always cons to a decision. Transversal adoption is still a controversial debate to the public at large and people argue over whether they agree or disagree or whether it is beneficial or not. Bottom line, most can agree on the fact that all hillier deserve to be in stable homes where the parents and family can love them unconditionally.